When it comes to precision flow measurement, two technologies often come head-to-head — Oval Gear Flowmeters and Coriolis Flowmeters. Both are known for their high accuracy and reliability, yet their working principles and ideal applications differ greatly. Understanding these differences is key to choosing the right meter for your process.
1. Working Principle Comparison
Oval Gear Flowmeter: Volumetric Measurement
An oval gear flowmeter operates on a positive displacement (PD) principle. It uses two oval-shaped gears that rotate as fluid passes through the measuring chamber. Each rotation displaces a fixed volume of liquid, and the number of rotations is directly proportional to the total volume.
Key Characteristics:
- Measures volumetric flow rate (L/min or m³/h)
- Ideal for clean, viscous, or lubricating fluids
- Unaffected by fluid density or temperature
Coriolis Flowmeter: Mass Measurement
The Coriolis flowmeter, on the other hand, measures mass flow directly. It works by vibrating a U-shaped or straight tube through which the fluid flows. The Coriolis effect — a slight phase shift caused by the moving fluid — is detected by sensors and converted into a mass flow rate.
Key Characteristics:
- Measures mass flow rate (kg/h or t/h) directly
- Simultaneously measures density and temperature
- Suitable for liquids, gases, and slurries
2. Accuracy and Performance
| Feature | Oval Gear Flowmeter | Coriolis Flowmeter |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy | ±0.2% to ±0.5% | ±0.1% or better |
| Repeatability | Excellent | Excellent |
| Effect of Viscosity | Accuracy increases with higher viscosity | Negligible |
| Effect of Density/Temperature | Requires correction | Compensated automatically |
Verdict:
If mass accuracy and multi-parameter measurement are critical (e.g., density, temperature), Coriolis is the better choice.
If you only need precise volumetric measurement of a viscous or lubricating liquid, an Oval Gear flowmeter provides great value and stability.
3. Application Suitability
| Application | Recommended Flowmeter | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel oil, lubrication oil, hydraulic oil | Oval Gear | Handles viscous, non-conductive liquids with stable accuracy |
| Chemical dosing, paint, resin | Oval Gear | Excellent for small batch and high-viscosity media |
| Food & beverage, pharmaceutical liquids | Coriolis | Hygienic design, density and temperature measurement |
| Gas measurement, multi-phase fluids | Coriolis | Direct mass measurement and wide fluid compatibility |
| Custody transfer or fiscal metering | Coriolis | High precision and traceability |
4. Installation and Maintenance
- Oval Gear Flowmeter:
Simple structure with minimal electronics; easy to maintain. Requires clean fluid to prevent gear wear. - Coriolis Flowmeter:
More complex and heavier; sensitive to vibration. Requires stable installation but needs almost no calibration once set up.
5. Cost and Return on Investment
- Oval Gear: Lower initial cost and maintenance, excellent for cost-sensitive applications.
- Coriolis: Higher upfront cost but provides mass flow + density + temperature in one instrument — often justified in high-value or critical processes.
6. Summary: How to Choose
| Selection Criteria | Best Choice |
|---|---|
| Measuring viscous liquids | Oval Gear |
| Need mass flow and density | Coriolis |
| Budget-sensitive application | Oval Gear |
| High-precision industrial control | Coriolis |
| Simple installation and low maintenance | Oval Gear |
Final Thoughts
Both Oval Gear and Coriolis Flowmeters deliver exceptional performance — the difference lies in what you want to measure and under what conditions.
If your application involves viscous liquids and you care about volume, choose Oval Gear.
If you need mass flow, density, and temperature in one, go with Coriolis.
👉 Looking for expert guidance? Contact our team for personalized advice.